According to a new report by Paul Tassi, via Forbes, Metacritic seems to be doing away with allowing users to submit scores on games until at least a day after release. Tassi notes that user scores for the just released Ghost of Tsushima only has critical scores posted for the game. The user scores are currently showing a message that user reviews will be permitted starting July 18 at 12PM (PT).
The message where the user score average would typically appear displays the following message to visitors.
Please spend some time playing the game.
Come back to review it starting at 12:00pm PST on July 18.
Come back to review it starting at 12:00pm PST on July 18.
Tassi speculates, and I have to echo his suspicions, that this was done in light of the recent review bombing that happened with The Last of Us Part 2. Internet trolls, bigots, and the like flocked to sites like Metacritic to review bomb the game down to a 3/10 right when the game was released. Some of those reviews flat out had gibberish for the written portion.
The initial issue was that there were thousands of reviews that came out almost instantly on the game’s release, when it was physically impossible for players to have played more than a couple hours, given that the length of the story was more like 20-30 hours. These people were submitting reviews based on things like story leaks, streamer playthroughs or just getting to a single story beat near the beginning and rushing off to write an angry review. This new 36-hour hold seems to be fighting against that directly.


