WTF, "Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery" in 1.03 patch!!!

[<{AU}>Westy]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Yeah it will backfire huge, no doubt about it, I personally think that should seriously re-consider there outlook on the whole punishment thing

[DU_is_good_4U]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

ya lets make a poll!!!

You spam up this site with too many of your stupid posts anyway.

[imported_Josh812]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Why will there be more munity votes? im confused, the commander will not kill you with arty, so why would you vote for this reason? It doesnt mean that he just doesnt get negative score for it, it means YOU WILL NOT DIE from arty, which is exactly what it says, no more tks from arty

[bam23]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

If you don't die from your own commander's arty, then that is ****ing stupid.

It should count as a suicide if it already doesn't.

[imported_madness]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

As I understand it, you die, but can't complain for the TK...
Idiot commanders may abuse that power and rape their team.

[2(x)ist]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Yes as i have allways been saying commanders should be immune to being punished for art kills...... its just dumb you allways have people that think they can dodge art or there god or what not and they run and the next thing you know your racking up negative points. So the commander shouldnt be punished for other people who are just dumb...

[Deipnosophist]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Let's look at this maturely, sure it compromises realism, but it saves a lot of problems. Commanders who actually do a good job will not have to put up with people running into enemy infested areas.

There are of course negatives, but you have to realise. There are probably DICE developers online every day of the week on this game, they know what's best for it...

[ShadowWarrior18D]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

They should be awarded (from Drexl):

The "Artillery in your area!!!" Ribbon

:laugh:

[<{AU}>Westy]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

oh yeah fun for all

[Harmor]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Why will there be more munity votes? im confused, the commander will not kill you with arty, so why would you vote for this reason? It doesnt mean that he just doesnt get negative score for it, it means YOU WILL NOT DIE from arty, which is exactly what it says, no more tks from arty

You won't be immune to artillery, your death just won't count as a TK.

We're not sure if the commander still get -4 teamwork points though.

[Harmor]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Yes as i have allways been saying commanders should be immune to being punished for art kills...... its just dumb you allways have people that think they can dodge art or there god or what not and they run and the next thing you know your racking up negative points. So the commander shouldnt be punished for other people who are just dumb...

Yeah, but we're not sure if they even get -4 points for killing you in the first place.

Normally you get -4 point for killing a teammate and then that teammate can assign an additional -4 points if he wants to punish you.

You will not be immune to your own artillery.

[Harmor]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Let's look at this maturely, sure it compromises realism, but it saves a lot of problems. Commanders who actually do a good job will not have to put up with people running into enemy infested areas.

Is it really your teammates fault if he enters an area with a bunch of enemies when he doesn't have a UAV over his head?

How does he know that there aren't like 5 guys there waiting for him...he doesn't. And so what happens is people like that may only see 1 enemy or none and get killed, thus one of the main reasons they punish the commander.

[Harmor]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

Personally the best idea I heard so far is as follows:

1. If a commander places an artillery strike on a teammate who is inside the area-of-effect then the commander gets -4 teamwork points, but the guy can't punish for an additional -4.
2. If a commander places an artillery strike and a teammate enters the area-of-effect then the player gets -2 points for basically suiciding.
3. When a commander places artillery a red canister is placed at the spot, just like when you are asked to defend or attack a location there's a purple and orange canisters:
   

The people in the modding forum said that this change would be pretty easy to implement since there's already code for attack/move/defend/mine/destroy orders for the commander that spawns a colored canister where the commander clicked.

[grrr]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

I think u will die, u just wont get TK scores from it, that all.
I havent tested it yet but il test it this evening.

[Harmor]

Re: WTF, &quot;Commander scoring - No more TKs from Artillery&quot; in 1.03 patch!!!

I think u will die, u just wont get TK scores from it, that all.
I havent tested it yet but il test it this evening.

Wait, you have access to the 1.03 patch?

Are you part of the WOLF clan?