War College Ribbon = stupid one ?

[X-ander]

Its 1 kill per 3 deaths so yes its a lame ribbon.

[excalibur69]

I think you can pretty much rule out the KDR thing. This guy recieved his WCR a few days ago and only has a 1.55KDR

http://www.bf2tracker.com/bf2_userawdstats.php?bf2id=6322284

I wish someone could get the facts straight....most of the commanders on the leaderboard dont even have this ribbon.

wow that is an amazing find man. i got to say, there is now hope for us that dont have a 3:1 K-D ratio. maybe its in the round you get the award only? guys UBAR missed it on that one

[Wranger4400]

It means greater than 1:3, like 1:2.

[sincles]

guess, im playing commander now for a while :P

[excalibur69]

well man, i wouldnt start playing till you know what the requirements are fully. for example, look at this guys stats

http://bf2s.com/player/godjoey/

he has ALOT more time and a higher commander score (& also a higher K-D ratio) than the guy who's link was posted above. he easily meets UBAR's requirements for the ribbon, but does not have it. I've looked a many profiles of the top commanders, and virtually none of them have it, which means there must be some other variable that no one is thinking of. Like I said, Ive looked through many profiles, but cant seem to find what the missing variable is

btw: here is the guys link in BF2S:
http://bf2s.com/player/[THC]Hunter-command/

[shaft]

Yeah i know..thats what gets me..ive been trying to get this ribbon for a week now. Ive got my 50hrs in, ive even have a 3.12KDR. And Ive had like 3 rounds now were I've scored well over 45 points. I took this last night.



There has to be some hidden requirement. Now if you dont even need a 3KDR its even easier then before, then why doesnt the majority of top commanders on the leaderboard have it?

[excalibur69]

ya man, exactly my point. i took a random sampling of about 25 people out of the top 40 commanders in BFHQ, and none of them had the ribbon, but this one guy with not that high a score has it. really odd...someone should email the UBAR guys to see if they can find out whats up with this

[x3phyr]

And Ive had like 3 rounds now were I've scored well over 45 points.

You do realize that it means a commander score of 45, right?

EDIT: Nevermind, I didn't see the Commander thing in the bottom left :p Been a long day.. Sorry..

[Sloi sauce]

Al Gore invented the War College Ribbon...

[[SIC]Squirrel.Lt.Col.]

Well this award to me sounds hard b/c i am usually not commander but a medic so i am usually running in front of a tank to get a revive........i do kill alot but i risk my life alot which has me to just abova a 1 kdr

[shaft]

ya man, exactly my point. i took a random sampling of about 25 people out of the top 40 commanders in BFHQ, and none of them had the ribbon, but this one guy with not that high a score has it. really odd...someone should email the UBAR guys to see if they can find out whats up with this

Exatcly..I did alot of clicking last night. Out of the top 100 commanders, only two guys have it.

G3157
[THC]Hunter-command

Everyone else has everything from thier Staff Officers Ribbon to Veteran Command. If the requirement were what they stated odds would have it that more then 2 people would have this. I emailed the ubars guys, lets see if they look into it.

[excalibur69]

cool man, please share with us if they email you anything back. i would love to know what they find as i want the whole collection of ribbons (if possible)

[sincles]

yar, any updates on this ribbon? im starting to command most of the battles now, so i hope this is not in vain

[shaft]

nothing yet....

[default]

I play commader 90% of the time, and my posistion is commander in my clan too, so this ribon would look pretty good lol. I havn't played long enough yet though, need another good 35 hours of commading, which i really enjoy doing, with the right squads of course. I got my staff officor ribbon too, so i have got over 45 in a round (without the x2). Would like to know how to get this ribon.

Edit:

acording to plannet battlefied 2 communtiy, this is the requirements:

The War College ribbon is awarded to recognize achievements which, through their dedication and gallantry, have set the individual apart and above other commanders.

Command Qualification: Skilled
Command Proficiency: Good
Command Rating: Outstanding

:~: Commander Score of 45 in 1 Round
:~: 50 Global Hours as Commander


does this mean you need to get exactly 45 commander points in one round?

Would be tricky, what happends if your on 45, and some one caps a flag lol, ull be above 45 then! lol. hmm.