I just had to comment on this...

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Petter

    #1

    I just had to comment on this...

    In this thread http://www.totalbf2.com/forums/showthread.php?t=62626 , lots of ppl blame the threadstarter to be a statpadder with what they claim to be obvious reasons.

    No offense maranello, but your math isnt very logical in ur post:

    "not possible. there are 300 tickets on both sides, 8 players on each team. if you scored 409 "legit" that would mean you had at least 100 kills, OR you were medic, the other team had that many kills, meaning those tickets would go down like crazy. ALSO, you having 409 points as infantry would mean rest of your teammates scored 20 or so points. It's just mathematically not possible."

    Its very much possible. Sure, 409 points is a LOT, but it is possible, especiallt if u play on a 64 player map with only 8 ppl on each side. Imagine how easy it would be to cap flags, which would give u 4 points each time. And he admits to having 108 kills, giving him 216 points just there. Add some medic and support points and it wouldnt be impossible to reach 400 points.

    And cybercrow, there is nothing that points to a statpadder in those examples u brought up:

    "looking at the difference between your win/loss you DEFFO swop over to the winning side.
    kill streak of 40 erm padding again were we?
    accuarcy 21% come on guys its all crap he needs wipe'n.
    726 pistol kills in 7hrs here it comes again padder.
    272 knife kills in 2HOURS LMFAO here it comes again padder."

    Ehm, he has a win:loss ratio of around 1.5 at max. Whats statpadding with that? Kill streak of 40, thats almost normal. Especially if he got it as a commander. There has been posts in this forum where ppl have boasted with streaks of around 100, so there is nothing wrong with that. Accuracy of 21%, pretty normal. And the "726 pistol kills in 7 hours" is not 7 hours straight u know. He has been playing for about 700 hours, and 7 of those he has been using his pistol and killed 726 ppl with it. Thats NORMAL... Same with the knife kills.

    And a nice finish with that "LOL U NOOB" comment. Really nice...

    Finally, he has been killed by the same guy 30 times in a single round. Sure, it sounds a bit suspicious, but remember that he likes to play on a 64 player server with 16 ppl on it. If a round lasts for about 2 hours, there is nothing surprising in getting killed by one guy 30 times.

    I'm not saying he isn't a statpadder, he could still be one, but u guys blame him to be one for the wrong reasons.

    Sorry for reopening a closed thread, but i just had to comment on this, cause i dont like it when ppl are being accused wrongly by someone who doesnt know what he is talking about... (no offense)
  • The_Misfit

    #2
    Re: I just had to comment on this...

    272 knife kills in 120 mins.

    272 / 120 = 2.26 kills per min with the knife.

    Factoring in time with it out in normal play (switching weapons, fooling around, etc) I find over 2 kills per min to be suspicious. You may not. To compare, I have .86 kills per min with the knife, and I'd suspect you'd find most normal players at ratios like that.

    Plus, stats were pulled from players this person plays with in that thread that helped show what was going on. And who posts a 409 score as a big deal when their previous best was 406? When I beat my best by 3 points I'll be sure to post it here as though I won the lottery.

    People that seek out and play on 64 player maps with 12-16 people tops raise suspicion, period. "Normal" gameplay is when the server is full or near-full. Ticket counts are designed for FULL servers, not when they have 20% of their population...

    Comment

    • imported_bingobones

      #3
      Re: I just had to comment on this...

      thx petter - i tried to explain but they take no notice!

      c u around m8...

      Comment

      • Frogatron

        #4
        Re: I just had to comment on this...

        Look at my kill streak - 46, commanding on Karkland when I first started playing, even I wondered wtf for a while! And I can never recollect being defibbed once however it's happened 99 times! Gave up on the knife and pistol badges after 1 attempt just way too boring..... My BR of 265 were gained under similar circumstances 64 server with less than 20 playing, there were guys there with higher scores and I wouldn't even class myself as remotely good, just enjoy the game and from my own experience, more than possible to get those stats.

        Comment

        • imported_bingobones

          #5
          Re: I just had to comment on this...

          ty frog

          Comment

          • A_Dirty_Hippie
            Member
            • Apr 2006
            • 145

            #6
            Re: I just had to comment on this...

            While I will agree that 16p on a 64p map might not be "normal" it is not illegal. As for his stats I have aproximately 3.14 kills per min with the knife. I also have aproximately 2.36 deaths per min.

            Now before you start screaming padder take into consideration I only have 16 kills with the knife. I think you stat enforcers are doing a great job but at times you seem to get a bit overzealous.

            He can think his score is a big deal and post about it all he wants. 409 good job. If you dont think its a big deal than good for you, no need to flame him.

            Comment

            • Warm Pudgy

              #7
              Re: I just had to comment on this...

              if you look at his top victims, and see their victims and enemies, its aparent that this group of people do nothing but stand around stat padding and killing each other







              all of them with the exception of the false account they made have well over a thousand knife kills or shock paddle kills

              Comment

              • imported_bingobones

                #8
                Re: I just had to comment on this...

                ty room420...

                pudgy would u care to explain urself?!!!! i have no idea what ur on about lol

                Comment

                • imported_qwerty

                  #9
                  Re: I just had to comment on this...

                  Since when did a 40 kill streak take statpadding...

                  Comment

                  • evilzucchini

                    #10
                    Re: I just had to comment on this...

                    To be honest, I find 406 points on an 8v8 on a 64 size map not all that surprising.

                    Considering that it takes so long to get that many points (as you said, 2 hours) the score/minute is not all that high (~3.3?).

                    On top of that, 2 knife kills per minute is ridiculously low if you know what you are doing. It only takes a second to whip out your knife, 1 second to stab (let's say you miss a few times, so we will say 5 seconds to kill) and then 1 second to put it away. If done correctly, that is less than 10 seconds for a knife kill which is more than 6 per minute.

                    What I don't understand is why the thread was closed at all. It was like the mod just wanted to get the last word in. Seems wrong to me.

                    Comment

                    • imported_bingobones

                      #11
                      Re: I just had to comment on this...

                      ty zuchinni :)

                      Comment

                      • BirdKiller
                        Member
                        • Feb 2005
                        • 785

                        #12
                        Re: I just had to comment on this...

                        Originally posted by The_Misfit
                        272 knife kills in 120 mins.

                        272 / 120 = 2.26 kills per min with the knife.

                        Factoring in time with it out in normal play (switching weapons, fooling around, etc) I find over 2 kills per min to be suspicious. You may not. To compare, I have .86 kills per min with the knife, and I'd suspect you'd find most normal players at ratios like that.
                        You have to realize that many players will only pull out their knife when the weapons is truly needed (last-ditch weapon) or wanted (humility) at certain events. Some will hold their knife whenever they're running into the hotzone, some will only pull out their knife when their target is only 2 meters away.

                        Comment

                        • LoKi.

                          #13
                          Re: I just had to comment on this...

                          Since when was this forum a PUBLIC COURT.

                          Ok so he is a padder but we dont want to hear about it here or we will be back to the state this forum was about a month back when every 2nd post was about some guy stat padding.

                          Take it to www.BF2rankedservers.com not in here Kthnxbye

                          Comment

                          • imported_bingobones

                            #14
                            Re: I just had to comment on this...

                            Originally posted by Inc|LoKi
                            Since when was this forum a PUBLIC COURT.

                            Ok so he is a padder but we dont want to hear about it here or we will be back to the state this forum was about a month back when every 2nd post was about some guy stat padding.

                            Take it to www.BF2rankedservers.com not in here Kthnxbye
                            NO IM NOT A STATPADDER
                            u have never played with me in game and u have no proof

                            noob

                            Comment

                            • menace-uk-
                              Member
                              • Apr 2006
                              • 615

                              #15
                              Re: I just had to comment on this...

                              I find it kind of sad that you people care what others are doing if some one wants to statpad so what they paid there money so they can do what they want.

                              Before you start saying oh look another stat padder check my stats out they are crap:laugh:


                              Wheather this person is statpadding or not has ****all to do with any of you stop bitching and play the game

                              Comment

                              Working...