TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • fate0521

    #16
    Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

    unless you have 2 ip addresses for global address on that router theres no way you can do it

    Comment

    • R3d|Rav3n

      #17
      Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

      a global address? that's a new one...

      Comment

      • darklegionca

        #18
        Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

        i love how people think they know wtf there talkin about when they actualy dont it's laughable

        Comment

        • DrunkenPirate
          Ascended
          • Mar 2005
          • 4210

          #19
          Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

          I am certain you can connect with the same IP address, there were 3 people on my server a few nights ago all with the same IP address.

          Comment

          • =ExM=Gunner

            #20
            Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

            you probaly need to assign internal ips on the router

            Comment

            • imported_Wreck

              #21
              Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

              Originally posted by jojobinkus
              EA support has just told me that my son and I cannot play BF2 on the same server, even though we each have our own copy of BF2 (legally purchased mind you)...

              Since we're behind a router, the server see's the same IP address, and so only one of us can join...

              There has GOT to be a way around this.

              Does anyone know how to address this issue?

              I will send a home baked chocolate chip cookie to whomever can fix this problem for us! (Damn good cookies!)

              Thanks for any info!

              Thats not true. I play with two copies from the same router at my house. In fact I play CSS, DOD, COD2, and BF2 from both PC's without issue or having to set up anything.

              Comment

              • scott123

                #22
                Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                Originally posted by jojobinkus
                EA support has just told me that my son and I cannot play BF2 on the same server, even though we each have our own copy of BF2 (legally purchased mind you)...

                Since we're behind a router, the server see's the same IP address, and so only one of us can join...

                There has GOT to be a way around this.

                Does anyone know how to address this issue?

                I will send a home baked chocolate chip cookie to whomever can fix this problem for us! (Damn good cookies!)

                Thanks for any info!

                I'm behind a router. My son and I have played on the same server many times. I never have had an issue.

                Comment

                • TSS SNIPE

                  #23
                  Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                  To the original poster...

                  jojobinkus

                  FACT: You can play with as many computers as your connection will support with one internet account.

                  FACT: I have a 3 mg x 3 meg connection at the house and we run four BF2 pc's on it at a time.

                  PORT FORWARDING is not the awnser.

                  If you can post what kind of router you have that would be great. Just reply here and we will get you going.

                  In a nutshell. Lets say your using a DSL connection with PPOE.

                  (Point to Point Protocol over Ethernet is a proposal specifying how a host personal computer (PC) interacts with a broadband modem (i.e. xDSL, cable, wireless, etc) to achieve access to the growing number of High speed data networks.)

                  Go into your router config and setup your router for PPOE. input your user ID and password. Your router will then conect to your IP and negotiate a IP address for your router. Setup your router for DHCP, don't forget to assign the ranges. Its a good Idea that if you have wireless at your house to limit the amount of addresses your DHCP sever will hand out. Example. If you have four machines set your DHCP to hand out only five addresses. 168.0.0.1 - 168.0.0.5. Its also a good idea to pick a ip range different from the standard 192.168.X.X ranges. (Security Reasons)

                  Once this is all done reboot the router and then each PC. Your PC's should get a IP from the router (Both different from each other) and then your good to go.

                  Well my batt is almost dead in my laptop so I will post more later.

                  Mike
                  Network Administrator

                  Comment

                  • NoSoup4You

                    #24
                    Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                    So now that we know EA hasn't limited the IP's to one per person per server we need to find out why his router isn't working.

                    If the two computers and networked they they each have thier own IP address internally as well.

                    This leads me to believe there is a problem with the CD-Keys or the router itself.

                    Comment

                    • jojobinkus

                      #25
                      Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                      Thanks for all the comments and replies...

                      Perhaps I need to do more testing...it didn't work on a few servers so I assumed....(never assume, it makes an ass out of u and me)

                      In any case, I have an SMC Barricade 7008ABR Router. I agree, port forwarding is not the answer, unless I was trying to host a game from behind my router.

                      I will continue testing, and let you all know how I make out.

                      Again, this forum was certainly the most productive for answers!

                      Thanks!
                      Jojo

                      Comment

                      • preem

                        #26
                        Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                        Originally posted by TSS SNIPE
                        Setup your router for DHCP, don't forget to assign the ranges. Its a good Idea that if you have wireless at your house to limit the amount of addresses your DHCP sever will hand out. Example. If you have four machines set your DHCP to hand out only five addresses. 168.0.0.1 - 168.0.0.5. Its also a good idea to pick a ip range different from the standard 192.168.X.X ranges. (Security Reasons)
                        Thats exactly how you do it. You must have a DHCP server, if you do not, you can use whatever old pc, pII 300Mhz would do it, just install linux and dhcp server.


                        Originally posted by KingOfKhaos
                        If the two computers and networked they they each have thier own IP address internally as well.
                        Yes they do, by default i think the routers are given one IP address, and all the computers connected to in, in LAN, are assigned ip addresses of 192.168.0.xx, something like that.

                        And you can tell right away IP address with ".0." in it, its not accessible from the internet.

                        So DHCP is your answer man.

                        Comment

                        • Gunny Highway

                          #27
                          Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                          Originally posted by Primski
                          Thats exactly how you do it. You must have a DHCP server, if you do not, you can use whatever old pc, pII 300Mhz would do it, just install linux and dhcp server.
                          Or you can use Windows and have it enable Internet Connection Sharing. It has a slimmed down and limited DHCP and DNS proxy service. Works just fine for most ppl.

                          Originally posted by Primski
                          And you can tell right away IP address with ".0." in it, its not accessible from the internet.
                          An .0. in an IP has nothing to do with it being a public or a private IP.

                          That is determinded by the IP ranges. E.g. these are private IPs everyone can use that aren't routeable on the Internet:

                          10.0.0.0-10.255.255.255
                          172.16.0.1-172.31.255.255
                          192.168.0.0-192.168.255.255

                          Comment

                          • preem

                            #28
                            Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                            Originally posted by Gunny Highway
                            Or you can use Windows and have it enable Internet Connection Sharing. It has a slimmed down and limited DHCP and DNS proxy service. Works just fine for most ppl.
                            Yeah that would work too. Tell me one thing thou, must you have Windows server, or will XP work ? Can you set up your own home desktop computer to do that, and what are his resource consumption then ? Will he be able to play games normaly or will that PC be too ocupied. in that case i recomend separte PC with linux. I have setup like that quite a few networks , and it works great. It only involves another old PC, you already threw out, or had it stored in the basement

                            Comment

                            • jojobinkus

                              #29
                              Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                              Good news!!!

                              I discovered my problem...I had configured my router to forward some ports to my dedicated BF2 server...

                              Once I disabled those ports being forwarded, my son and I were able to join the same internet server at the same time!!! WOO HOO!!!

                              Thanks all for a great discussion on this issue...

                              By the way, my subject "TICKED OFF" still applies...The EA Support rep who told me I was out of luck obviously had NO FRIGGIN CLUE what he was talking about....

                              Comment

                              • Spr1ngY

                                #30
                                Re: TICKED OFF! Need expert advice!

                                me and my room mate play of the same 2meg router and we alwayz play bf2 on the same sever??

                                Comment

                                Working...