BF or CoD knifing?

[Lt Davis]

I like how the knives operate now myself, but I wouldn't cry if the range were reduced by 25-50% either.

Remember what happened to BF when they started changing stuff like that...

i personally dont think this is a fair test because in my experience the NO hit knife animation and the HIT knife animation are different, when you connect the kill, the player seem to move forward about 2 metres, this doesnt happen when not connecting.

Yeah, because in real life you're going to try and slash across your enemy's back while keeping your arm right next to your body.

[TSlaw*]

Yeah, because in real life you're going to try and slash across your enemy's back while keeping your arm right next to your body.

And you are jumping around corners at a full run into a hail of bullets, THEN respawning, and full of ammo. Yup.

[imported_Whiskey]

when you connect the kill, the player seem to move forward about 2 metres

Hmm...doesn't seem to happen on my game. I've never seen this.

[Kylee!]

Funniest thing ever said. The hit detection is horrible in CoD4. It is really kind of annoying and frustrating.

Zomg, you is playing on the PS3... We have patches bro. :yay:

I love the kickass animation for the CoD4 knifing. :P

BF2 was just... I dunno, boring, even if it did give you a bit more satisfaction because it was harder to do, but the CoD4 knife still has a very high humiliation factor.

[The_Eliminator]

Remember what happened to BF when they started changing stuff like that...



Yeah, because in real life you're going to try and slash across your enemy's back while keeping your arm right next to your body.

i thought we were talking about CoD4.

[Lt Davis]

You're the one who brought up realism.

[TheDesert_Fox]

You're the one who brought up realism.

Sorry to intrude but you brought up realism:

Yeah, because in real life you're going to try and slash across your enemy's back while keeping your arm right next to your body.

Eliminator never said it was unrealistic how you seem to move forward.

[The_Eliminator]

Guys i didnt want to start an argument here, i just gave my opinion on the matter and we all are going to have our own. :)

[iQue]

Guys i didnt want to start an argument here, i just gave my opinion on the matter and we all are going to have our own. :)

Indeed.

I like the BF knife better overall but I agree that the CoD animation is cool.

I tend to have the same feeling as The_Eliminator, it really feels like you're being pushed forward two meters when you knife sometimes.

[Kodakk]

Indeed.

I like the BF knife better overall but I agree that the CoD animation is cool.

I tend to have the same feeling as The_Eliminator, it really feels like you're being pushed forward two meters when you knife sometimes.

Yeah, my friend - who's new to CoD4 - described it as flying across the map. :)

[Stigmata]

im going with BF2142 on this one. BF is more of a slash then stab like COD4, and i actually like the fact that BF can be hard and misses alot. the one on one challenges in BF are def better to, ive yet to even see a one on one challenge in COD4, i just dont like the whole 2 meter lunge thing, but i guess it fits the fast arcade style of COD4. oh, and obviously, 2142 keeps track of dogtags, nuff said :p

[Lt Davis]

Sorry to intrude but you brought up realism:
Eliminator never said it was unrealistic how you seem to move forward.

He never said it directly, but I got the impression that it was his complaint.

[The_Eliminator]

I didnt mean it that way but i see where you were coming from, i personally dont think this game is any more realistic than your average FPS, some people seem to think it is, we all got our own opinions on it. :)

[PeteDude]

Thr COD4 knifeing suits COD4 more and BF way is better in BF.

[=)BiT(=BlackMage]

Thr COD4 knifeing suits COD4 more and BF way is better in BF.

I don't think this forum can take such an injection of common sense.