GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Mr.Arabian

    #1

    GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

    hi guys

    I found that in www.gamespot.com


    BF2



    BF2 : SF



    what do you think , Is that true
    BF2 is more better than BF2:SF !!
  • Deadpoetic

    #2
    Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

    why did they put a 8 for SF graphics...its the same freaking engine!!

    Comment

    • ammar

      #3
      Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

      i dunno .. but if you ask me .. SF sucks from the screenshots etc. ! so i did not buy it ! :/

      Comment

      • Mr.Arabian

        #4
        Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

        Originally posted by DeadPoetic
        why did they put a 8 for SF graphics...its the same freaking engine!!
        yes ,, Must be 10 like BF2

        maybe 8 because dark and night map

        Comment

        • Attila

          #5
          Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

          Originally posted by DeadPoetic
          why did they put a 8 for SF graphics...its the same freaking engine!!
          Because it's 6 months later. Hell didn't Op Flashpoint get a really high graphics score?

          SF got a lower score because it's cumulative with BF2, they scored it as a separate entity. Value went down because it doesn't add all that much to the original, and gameplay went down because of performance issues; notice where it says Stability: Major Problems. On the other hand, it says Battlefield 2 is "Stable", so...

          Comment

          • vbl

            #6
            Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

            Because, all else being equal, it's not as good?

            Comment

            • A$$a$$ination

              #7
              Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

              That's wierd with the graphics scores isn't it.

              Comment

              • Cerixus

                #8
                Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                Maybe the graphics score includes the hardware requirements. I know I was extremely disappointed that I had to change my anti-aliasing from 4x to 2x due to some jerkiness on night maps. I mean, I just spent 2 grand on a PC so I could play BF2 on the highest settings.

                Comment

                • BirdKiller
                  Member
                  • Feb 2005
                  • 785

                  #9
                  Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                  Originally posted by ||ass||variable
                  Because, all else being equal, it's not as good?
                  The score would be equal had the elements be judged by the standards six months ago.

                  Comment

                  • [Yezus]Aistis999

                    #10
                    Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                    bf2 is better then sf

                    Comment

                    • Bahraini_Killer

                      #11
                      Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                      I cant say much I dont have SF yet where I live...

                      everything is bad with me...ping is too high cant play much....rarely have a chance playing this great game....

                      Comment

                      • DrMcleod

                        #12
                        Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                        ...because technology has moved on. What scored a 10 five years ago wouldn't rate a 10 today. Get it?

                        Comment

                        • vbl

                          #13
                          Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                          Originally posted by Bird Killer
                          The score would be equal had the elements be judged by the standards six months ago.
                          But that's not reality. So maybe everyone who takes exception to the rating should work toward putting the score in perspective, not as being worse, but as being the best possible score given the new standards.

                          Plus, I don't believe that DICE Canada has as high quality an output as the Swedish office. I felt that BF1942 was better than BFV, despite being older. Gamespot rated BFV .3 points lower than BF1942, even though BFV came out 2 years after BF1942.

                          Comment

                          • raceacontari

                            #14
                            Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                            thats how gamespot is with their ranking systems. Why is it the same game but for different systems (pc, xbox, etc) can have such a difference in score? Just look at Battlefront 2 on gamespot, the xbox version is the "best" in their opinion compared to all the others.

                            So in otherwords, don't even look at those scores, its just their opinion about a game. The only scores I look at on gamespot are the ones actual people who've played it submitted

                            Comment

                            • BurnTheWeed

                              #15
                              Re: GameSpot : 9.3 for BF2 , 8.1 for BF2:SF [why]

                              It's not like they have some set test that determines that score, they just judge it based on what they thought about it at the time and then make up whatever numbers they feel like

                              Comment

                              Working...