M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jedi_Joe

    #16
    Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

    yeah P90 all the way :)
    if on;y it had more ammo clips

    Comment

    • Chris_Redfield
      Member
      • Oct 2006
      • 5986

      #17
      Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

      If its MP5 vs M4A1 for CQB, I would pick MP5. I aim for the head, and the bullet deviation is or seems smaller than the M4A1s, but the ROF punches out more bullets, which results in a dead enemy. The only problem is fighting against weapons that deal 1 shot headkills.

      Comment

      • jdrou
        Member
        • Jul 2006
        • 1860

        #18
        Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

        M4 is better in CQB. MP5 has 50% higher RoF but M4 does >50% more damage per round so it balances out. M4's far better accuracy gives it the win.

        The P90 is only very slightly more accurate than the MP5; its major advantage is the larger mag. DAO-12 beats everything in CQB.

        Comment

        • Cromat

          #19
          Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

          M4

          But MP5 is the best SMG at point blank range IMO

          Comment

          • jdrou
            Member
            • Jul 2006
            • 1860

            #20
            Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

            Originally posted by Cromat
            But MP5 is the best SMG at point blank range IMO
            All the SMGs are pretty much identical except for ammo capacity (and the P90's small acc advantage). The 45- and 50-round mags could make the difference when you run into multiple enemies.

            Comment

            • Sir. HackerX4

              #21
              Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

              I would take the engineer shotty to someones face anyday

              but I love my MP5, M4 is overratted...

              Comment

              • gunitsoldier127

                #22
                Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                mp5 with high rate of fire downs enemy faster than the m4 in my opinion, well where i play no one ever proved me wrong... and if ur not convinced i play at moders karkand, go and check it out urself.

                Comment

                • Papi4baby
                  Member
                  • Aug 2005
                  • 1189

                  #23
                  Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                  Like Redfield said. For CQB MP5. And since your enemy is armored, and in real life if you have info that the asailant has armor, you will go in doing headshots. And that's how special teams are trained with the MP5 headshots nice and fast.

                  Comment

                  • SERIALBUTCHER

                    #24
                    Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                    Last night I pulled out the G36C for the first time in months, after teaching myself to be almost snipe accurate w/ the RPK-74 using the G36C was ridiculusly easy, I was winning prone wars against PKM's w/ astonishing regularity

                    W/ the F2000, or the M4 I had to break myself of the habit of proning so as to not get pwned by support players w/ PKM's

                    @ medium range the G36C's accuracy > than the PKM's power, & the sight picture is wonderful to me

                    It is kinda' like a G36E w/ full auto

                    imvho

                    Lieutenant General |SI|SERIALBUTCHER

                    peace:)

                    Comment

                    • Sike
                      Member
                      • Jun 2006
                      • 1742

                      #25
                      Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                      i wish that instead of the M16/M203 uwe could have a M1A1 carbine/m203

                      Comment

                      • SERIALBUTCHER

                        #26
                        Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                        Originally posted by Cromat
                        M4

                        But MP5 is the best SMG at point blank range IMO
                        Better than the MP7?

                        I don't know about that 1

                        LG SB

                        peace:)

                        Comment

                        • jdrou
                          Member
                          • Jul 2006
                          • 1860

                          #27
                          Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                          Originally posted by SERIALBUTCHER
                          Better than the MP7?

                          I don't know about that 1
                          The same conditions I posted earlier about the P90 apply to the MP7: it has a very slight accuracy advantage and more rounds in the mag. P90>MP7>MP5 but that's not saying much. The SMGs are much better than they were in v1.00 but they still can't match a shotgun or assault rifle in CQB and can't match much of anything at longer ranges except shotguns.

                          Comment

                          • MrBenis

                            #28
                            Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                            Originally posted by SERIALBUTCHER
                            Last night I pulled out the G36C for the first time in months, after teaching myself to be almost snipe accurate w/ the RPK-74 using the G36C was ridiculusly easy, I was winning prone wars against PKM's w/ astonishing regularity

                            W/ the F2000, or the M4 I had to break myself of the habit of proning so as to not get pwned by support players w/ PKM's

                            @ medium range the G36C's accuracy > than the PKM's power, & the sight picture is wonderful to me

                            It is kinda' like a G36E w/ full auto

                            imvho

                            Lieutenant General |SI|SERIALBUTCHER

                            peace:)
                            THat's because PKM got ass****ed in 1.4, the idiots at DICE nerfed it again.

                            Your accomplishment is minimal.

                            Comment

                            • SERIALBUTCHER

                              #29
                              Re: M4A1 vs MP5 in CQB

                              Originally posted by MrBenis
                              THat's because PKM got *******ed in 1.4, the idiots at DICE nerfed it again.

                              Your accomplishment is minimal.
                              Dude, the thread topic is about a comparison between a carbine, & a smg, can a guy make a comment on his experience w/ carbines lately w/ out being cut down by forum trolls

                              My point is you still should not insta-prone against a PKM, but I still do it out of habit because I play support a lot, but after making this usually fatal error I still came out on top most of the time, in sitiations where if I were playing assault I don't think I would have prevailed, & I didn't have to concentrate hard on aiming, just point it @ their head, & pull the trigger

                              sheeez

                              Lieutenant General |SI|SERIALBUTCHER

                              peace

                              Comment

                              Working...