Edited by [user="173994"] @ [time="1098978804"]
Really not that nice.
First off, the model. The quality of the modelling is good, though this comes at the price of a 6266 poly count, which is high for a rifle model even by today's standards, and seems a bit pointless since frankly there are equally nice models out there with 1/2 the poly count - so this just pointlessly alienates people. Still, the modelling is good.
Now the skin. Pretty nasty really. It's got an ugly tint to it which is very strong in some parts and then almost non-existant in other areas, which just makes the tint effect even more annoying then it is already. The skin is also under contrasted in some areas randomly, which doens't help it. Other then that it's just a pretty average skin by today's standards.
The animations are boring as hell, and are painfully and unnaturally exact and precise, and they don't flow well at all. For example, the shoot animation is a straight forward slam backwards. While in text this sounds normal, in reality it's literally just a backwards movement, and that's unnatural feeling and thus, bad. Jennifer!! is a decent animator, he just needs to put a more natural flow in 'em. It should also be noted that these animations carry with them one very nasty origin.
Overall, I really wouldn't bother with this replacement given that all the other replacements on the first page of the M4A1 archives (and some on the second) are superior to this. Personally I recommend this myself. Anyway, I won't be keeping this replacement in my models folder for any longer, and I'd be surprised if anyone else did.
It should also be noted that to get to this model you need an extra program called WinRAR as the standard WinZIp won't be enough, so make sure you go get WinRAR before downloading this model.
EDIT:
Well obviously this is just my opinion. That's kinda the point.
Comment