Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MrKLM
    Member
    • Apr 2006
    • 3146

    #1

    Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

    Don Reisinger of Cnet has an interesting article regarding Xbox LIVE and why it should now become free. Read On:
    Over the weekend, I spent some time playing online. I did so on Xbox Live and through games on both my PS3 and Wii. All the while, I was thinking about the one simple fact that kept sticking out in my head: for now at least, I can play online with my Wii and Playstation 3 and the experience is basically the same.

    And considering Microsoft keeps losing ground to both Sony and Nintendo, why not find a new way to offer a more compelling alternative out of the company's most popular service?

    Sure, it sounds radical and losing $50 per year from the millions of Xbox Live subscribers may be a major sticking point here, but it needs to be done. Microsoft's latest NPD numbers have been less than stellar and the Wii, DS, Playstation 3, and the PSP all sold better than the company's console in July. And if you want to compete in the hardware business, that's simply unacceptable.

    To make matters worse, the big lead Microsoft had over Sony in the third-party sphere is practically eliminated and it doesn't look like Nintendo will slow down anytime soon, nor will the Xbox 360 become a force in Asia.

    So what does Microsoft need to do to right the ship and really turn things around? Announce that all Xbox Live memberships will be free and all gamers can play online without a hitch. It's radical, for sure, but it's the best move Microsoft can make right now.

    It's about the size

    Making Xbox Live free to all gamers allows Microsoft to boast that it has the largest network of multi-platform users in the world. Right now, Microsoft is trying to become the world's leader in multi-platform gaming. And although it has done relatively well considering Xbox 360 sales have not matched competitors and Games for Windows Live is shaky, while Zune ownership is suspect, it will immediately put Microsoft into a position where developers can truly create a "Microsoft Experience."

    Is there a need to do so?

    Invariably, this argument will go to the argument that if people are willing to pay now, why should Microsoft tell them they don't have to? Why buy the cow if you can get the milk for free?

    But that argument is extremely short-sighted and fails to truly address what's going on in the market. Xbox Live is the cornerstone of Microsoft's broader gaming strategy. Without it, the Xbox 360 wouldn't be half as popular as it is today and it's still the only real benefit that still looms over Sony's head.

    Realizing that, Sony has consistently said that it plans on rolling out a major online initiative that revolves around its trust in Home and its aims are firmly planted on Microsoft. But in order to compete, Sony will need to pull out all the stops and try to create an experience that either matches or eclipses the ease with which we play games on Xbox Live. And to be honest, I think Sony can do it eventually. Read More...

    So let us know, would you be more willing to have an Xbox 360 if LIVE became free? And for those of you who have paid the money each month for LIVE how would you feel if it suddenly became free after all that money you spent on it.
  • TheHeartSmasher
    The Architect
    • Dec 2006
    • 696

    #2
    Re: Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

    I don't mind paying a small $50.00 a year for virtually perfect online service for the console.

    Plus there is a free version of XBOX Live called Silver instead of Gold. Microsoft's original goal was to get their consoles into the home no matter what it takes. They achieved this and even at a loss, this is Microsoft and the other side of the business makes up all the losses in about a week or two for all XBOX360s and XBOX consoles sold.

    The service is way above any other service even on our beloved PC, a central online friends list, really good matchmaking, voice/video chat that is so easy a caveman can do it, by pressing a few buttons here and there and they are done.

    I don't think it should be free as from free services so massive normally comes crappy service or unexpected services like the Wii and PS3 have at rare times. Plus the $50.00 a year is only about $4.17 a month which is extremely affordable and an acceptable/affordable pricing for such a great service (it should be more like $15.00-$20.00 a month as it far superior to most of the online MMOs that are priced too much per month). Plus the majority of people that cannot afford to pay such a low price are children which is a growing problem on the multiplayer MA rated games that they should not be playing.

    Comment

    • CaptainKirk

      #3
      Re: Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

      I've been paying the $50/year since Halo 2 came out and it has been worth every penny.

      Comment

      • Iwantcable
        Member
        • Jul 2007
        • 2362

        #4
        Re: Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

        Originally posted by TheHeartSmasher
        I don't mind paying a small $50.00 a year for virtually perfect online service for the console.

        Plus there is a free version of XBOX Live called Silver instead of Gold. Microsoft's original goal was to get their consoles into the home no matter what it takes. They achieved this and even at a loss, this is Microsoft and the other side of the business makes up all the losses in about a week or two for all XBOX360s and XBOX consoles sold.

        The service is way above any other service even on our beloved PC, a central online friends list, really good matchmaking, voice/video chat that is so easy a caveman can do it, by pressing a few buttons here and there and they are done.

        I don't think it should be free as from free services so massive normally comes crappy service or unexpected services like the Wii and PS3 have at rare times. Plus the $50.00 a year is only about $4.17 a month which is extremely affordable and an acceptable/affordable pricing for such a great service (it should be more like $15.00-$20.00 a month as it far superior to most of the online MMOs that are priced too much per month). Plus the majority of people that cannot afford to pay such a low price are children which is a growing problem on the multiplayer MA rated games that they should not be playing.
        [PC defense mode]

        Silver is useless since you can't actually play online.

        Central friends list: Xfire.
        Matchmaking: This is a personal opinion, but I much prefer being able to join a game with the exact map, player count, gametype, and rules whenever I want on PC. If you do like matchmaking, PC is most definitely lacking.
        Voice/Video chat: Again there's a ton of options. Not to mention group voice chat software like TS and Vent.

        $15-20 a month, are you mad? While I agree that MMOs are overpriced, I see no reason to pay $15-20 a month for something that's freely available to PC users.

        Hell there's even DLC that's free on PC, but despite having XBL Gold, you have to pay for (COD4 maps for example). Don't even get me started on paying for "Gamer pics" or "Themes" for games that you paid $60 for.

        [/PC defense mode]

        However, Microsoft aren't stupid. They know they have a heavy draw from exclusives that will keep people paying, so I would be very surprised to see anything done to make it cheaper.

        Comment

        • TheHeartSmasher
          The Architect
          • Dec 2006
          • 696

          #5
          Re: Why Xbox Live gaming should be free for all

          Yeah I don't think they should charge for the maps but the additional clothing and other things that do not affect gameplay are ok to charge for since they don't really do anything for you. The good thing with XBOX Live is it is all in one place, and is almost never down and just works. Xfire is ok but not as smooth as xbox live since xfire is not built into the game, but teamspeak 3 will be built into games. Yes our PC is far superior then any console will ever be, but the console does have everything virtually centralized with little to no configuration which makes things easy for your average gamer, which a PC Gamer is not since they play PC Games :) (Your average PC Gamer is far more advanced then your average console player).

          Comment

          Working...