what about if you got a point everytime you forgave a tk but none if you punish ...
-
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
I've always thought it would be nice that forgiving the person would not give them a negative score, and punishing them would give them those -4 points. -
Re: forgive / punish idea
Hmmmmmm?M?M?M?M?M?M?M?M?
Then people would be tempted to let intentional TKers go free. I do think it is better than the system now though.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
Its a good idea and would help in deminishing the rampant tk punish issue. But it doesnt make sense when implemented in the scoring system.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
Then it's gives another reason for people to Stat Pad.
Clan member tk's other clan member. Other clan member forgives, giving point. Clan member no. 1 revives no. 2, and the circle goes on.......Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
Youve got it al worked out in your head huh? lol, j/kOriginally posted by D_Lusted
speaking of the padding i just got banned from a server twice because they were pading and i interupted it by killing the enemy and their medic. LOL) fun stuff messing with these porr people.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
How about you learn to speak English properly so that when you flame you don't look like even more of a tool.Originally posted by Is_Your_Problem
The punish system could be made so much better by making it impossible to punish for kills by friendly claymore and AT mines.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
OMG..flame alert
Anyway, Not a bad idea but I do see some disadvantages. As D_Lusted said it does give people the opportunity to exploit. My only disagreement with his statement is he talks of clan people...its not only clan people that exploit things. Groups of friends, and Im sure we all have a group of friends that play together online, clanned or not that, could exploit this if they chose to.
I dont like the intentional tk's, they actually frustrate me to no end, but you learn to play smarter and besides that, on my side Im a forgiver
unless they shoot me in the face or do something equally intentionalthen I will punish.. This goes for jets that always seem to bomb a total squad of 6 to take out one enemy that has been spotted. All it accomplishes is us getting a higher ticket bleed due to our deaths and the enemy getting a lower one. Now that's just plain stupid and deserves a punish.
Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
I agree that the system needs work but the giving of points wouldnt work. You would get stat padders teamkilling, reviving and then getting points for saying.. Hey i forgive you...
I think the system should have accidental tk's for mines and claymores removed. Not sure about road kills though. Many a time I have been mowed down just cause some one cannot drive properly or didn't care. Nothing to do with me running in the way.
Perhaps punishes should do nothing more than be an automatic nomination for team only boots. i.e. if you get two punish for tks all team members get a vote saying xyz has been automatically nominated for two teamkills. Then if more people vote yes than No or abstain that teamkiller gets kicked. Note I say than abstain. I think its stupid when you need 40 votes to kick and only 32 on each side lol.
On that note the number of votes needed should be an equation of the number of minus points and the relation to people on the team. ie the more negative points the fewer yes votes needed.
Edited to add
Actually on that note their history of punishes and team kills could be loaded with them at game start and the votes needed to kick could be altered accordingly. i.e. if this player tk's for planes EVERY game then he needs just a couple of votes. If he has never tked before (yeah like its his first game) then he might need the whole team to vote him out.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
If a clan decided to stats pad that way it still wouldnt be as efficient as the traditionnal knife-revive-knife... The only advantage would be that it would be harder to spot stats padders by looking at their stats because they wont have their favorite victim at 50+ kills. So Dice would have to put a limit on the forgiving (max 2 forgive points per teammate) to prevent stats padding but i stilll think its a good idea.Originally posted by D_LustedComment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
Originally posted by kingskinUK
Haha....nice! Don't you love it when someone tries to be a smartass and put someone else down...and ends up looking the ass.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
You guys aren't thinking these things out...Originally posted by kingskinUK
Imagine DICE did that, then you have a bunch of ass holes laying claymores all over their teams base.Comment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
i like it for now and the one that started to flame suddenly about punishing, ur a retard..cuz its a very good idea but i wont like it cuz of paddingComment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
Some people... :hmm: i think its a very good idea!Originally posted by Is_Your_ProblemComment
-
Re: forgive / punish idea
I mentioned in another forum, what i thought was i good idea, that tk's lead to demotion in rank and loss of unlock, if you get rewarded for fair and good play then i can't see why you could'nt get demoted for bad play.
or am i missing a point here. comments please.Comment
Comment