Bad Commander?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • strathound

    #1

    Bad Commander?

    Ok, so it generally considered poor form to call Artillery Strikes on the opponent's airplane hangers? Is this spamming?

    The reason I ask is I was commanding on Killer Old Farts clan server last night and one of their clan members sent a Team message saying, "Commander, hey thanks for doing something useful. How about using the Arty for something strategic and helping us out down here, Jeez."

    Well I was kind of shocked. Now, don't get me wrong. The KoF guys are great to play with. They work well as a team and actually listen to the commander. I enjoyed playing with them. But I wondered if I had wandered over the line of protocol by killing their clan members on the other team who were waiting for the jets to spawn.

    For those KoF guys reading this, let me explain what I was trying to do. We had just lost a rear base and I'm a BIG proponent of keeping the rear bases. It helps mobilize the big attack if you have clear sailing into the enemy zone. Anyways, we had a zerg going on at this rear base. The enemy had launched a balanced attack with an armored column, infantry and attack helicopter. They weren't going to be rolled very easily. So I was overly concerned and spending most of my time doing scans with the UAV and dropping supplies where the troops could use them. Then the enemy began pummelling our boys with Arty and I realized that I had let up on him. I did a quick scan and there weren't any interesting targets that didn't already have a bunch of my boys down on the ground and engaged. So rather than let the enemy continue to pummel us without retribution, my scan pointed out that there were some spawn campers waiting on the jets in the enemy base. Well, shoot, I didn't want those guys getting into the air. We already had our hands full. So every chance I got, if I didn't have a strategic target, I made sure we kept those jets on the ground. That meant pummeling the #@$# out of those hangers.

    Anyways, the results were good. We won 3 in a row while I was commander. So I guess it was working. :)


    Michael
  • Guidon666

    #2
    Re: Bad Commander?

    I will often arty the hangars if there are no other viable targets or the other target locations are full of friendlies.

    Never a short for killing one or more people back there as there is usually someone waiting for a plane/helicopter...etc.

    Comment

    • Eddie Haskell

      #3
      Re: Bad Commander?

      The only "poor form" I'm aware of is dropping artillery on your teammates or blasting the ocean. If you're the commander, target whatever you want, if the game allows it, whiners will just have to deal with it or kick vote.

      Comment

      • imported_DaDDeh

        #4
        Re: Bad Commander?

        If i'm playing commander (Mec) on Operation Clean Sweep, I always pummel the USMC airbase, everyround there will be campers for the jets and helis, keeping there air assets grounded helps win that map.

        Comment

        • 193d DCAT1

          #5
          Re: Bad Commander?

          If it keeps good pilots out of the air for even a minute or two, it is a good tactic.

          Comment

          • imported_Rafterman
            Member
            • May 2005
            • 1105

            #6
            Re: Bad Commander?

            I don't have a problem with it. I could see if it was needed somewhere else by your team, but if not, then go for it.

            If the other team complains, it's b/c they're a bunch of whiny babies anyway. They shouldn't be plane camping.

            Comment

            • F-1

              #7
              Re: Bad Commander?

              I saw an even worse case...

              I was the commander of the USMC in Karkand and the MEC commander kept bombarding me with the arty while I was commanding from the main base.

              Well, that idiot killed me only twice and lost a lot of strikes just to annoy me. He could kill a sniper hiding somewhere or do what ever! that definitly did not help his team, and all I lost was 15secx2 to respawn.

              The problem is that he did not help his team and did not get a single point for killing me.

              Of course they lost that game.

              Comment

              • spartan915

                #8
                Re: Bad Commander?

                I have no problem with this tactic because it attempts to address an issue I think is becoming a major problem in the game. I hate people who camp waiting for vehicles while the rest of the team is getting wasted trying to take spawn points and need the help. I think the only thing that is “poor form” is a commander who makes no attempt to communicate with the team and answer Supply/UAV/Arty requests. As far as dropping arty on your on team, if one guy is surrounded then I try to warn him before I shoot. If more than one team member is present I look someplace else unless they request it

                Comment

                • strathound

                  #9
                  Re: Bad Commander?

                  That's pretty much what I thought guys thanks. I might have misinterpreted the comment as well. Maybe I wasn't being effective enough with it. But it's always easier to be critical when you aren't looking at the Commander Screen.

                  :)

                  Comment

                  Working...