hit reg

[Sir401]

Re: hit reg

Lets give EA some credit, ever since patch 1.5 people don't whore jets as much now that missles are serious buisiness.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

Tomeis, infantry hit registration is no way "perfect" for me. Its actually on the same level of 1.41. Considering youve been here since 2007, you should know that BF2 hitreg is different in different setups. I get a ton of yellow puffs with a ping below 50. And yet, my air hitboxes and hit detection is awesome.

I never said it isn't perfect for everyone, but it's perfect for me, and that guy is trying to tell me otherwise.

I don't even play on servers with <50 ping. It's always 70 - 120. My specs are on the side, and I've got a 30mbps line. Like I said, it sucks for people who have problems, but please don't pretend to know how the game plays for me.

[johnrondot]

Re: hit reg

I never said it isn't perfect for everyone, but it's perfect for me, and that guy is trying to tell me otherwise.

I don't even play on servers with <50 ping. It's always 70 - 120. My specs are on the side, and I've got a 30mbps line. Like I said, it sucks for people who have problems, but please don't pretend to know how the game plays for me.

I don't believe you.Sorry,but test it with a friend or someone and get back to me.I bet you see puffs of smoke instead of 100% hits.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

I don't believe you.Sorry,but test it with a friend or someone and get back to me.I bet you see puffs of smoke instead of 100% hits.

I honestly don't care if you don't believe me. I have fun playing the game, and you don't. That pretty much means that I win.

[[GCA]Tim270]

Re: hit reg

I honestly don't care if you don't believe me. I have fun playing the game, and you don't. That pretty much means that I win.

Fail post is fail.

He came here to discuss the hitboxes in there current state and they are by no means perfect for anyone, you may have got used to a bad system and made the best out of it, but that does not change the fact they are still essentially broken.
I agree with the OP in that the hitboxes alone have stopped me from playing the game quite a bit, at least If I have been playing a CoD game before, it just feels so off.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

Fail post is fail.

He came here to discuss the hitboxes in there current state and they are by no means perfect for anyone, you may have got used to a bad system and made the best out of it, but that does not change the fact they are still essentially broken.

If it's true that I've made the best out of a bad system then WOW! I did it without even realising it! It must be pretty easy, then. Why can't you guys do the same?

[[GCA]Tim270]

Re: hit reg

If it's true that I've made the best out of a bad system then WOW! I did it without even realising it! It must be pretty easy, then. Why can't you guys do the same?

I think I can speak for everyone in this thread when I say we know how to play the game, but simply being able to play it or be good at it does not that the hitboxes are correctly implemented.

Why cant everyone 'do the same' as you? because believe it or not watching dust come out of someone's head that you are shooting at is retarded.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

I think I can speak for everyone in this thread when I say we know how to play the game, but simply being able to play it or be good at it does not that the hitboxes are correctly implemented.

Why cant everyone 'do the same' as you? because believe it or not watching dust come out of someone's head that you are shooting at is retarded.

Well, like I've been saying over and over, I've never had any problems with the hit reg, and I never see dust and not see an X. LoL. Am I lucky? Maybe? But BF2 is still one of the top 5 most popular FPS, so clearly there are either a lot of people who aren't making a big deal out of it like you guys are, or there are A LOT of lucky people.

[[GCA]Tim270]

Re: hit reg

If its such a minor issue then why was it one of the major 'selling points' of the 1.5 patch? with a huge community demand for it.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

If its such a minor issue then why was it one of the major 'selling points' of the 1.5 patch? with a huge community demand for it.

I don't remember it being a major "selling point" at all. In fact, I don't even remember it being part of the patch.

http://blogs.battlefield.ea.com/bf2_2142/archive/2009/08/27/battlefield-2-update-v1-50-is-almost-here.aspx

A little bit less than half way down the "Gameplay tweaks" list:
"- Tweaked the hit detection, hits will be more accurate to the model."

Not even bolded, or on the top of the list. Not "overhauled the hit detection", just a simple "tweak".

Plus, this was about hit detection being accurate to the model NOT "hits not registering at all, period."

You guys are complaining about the part that I bolded, NOT the part that I italicized.

Before, when I would use the TV missile, I would have to hit behind an enemy helicopter, like where its tail is. Now, I can actually aim right for the body of the chopper. Did it make a difference for me? Not really. I was getting kills with the TV missile before, and I'm getting just as many now. All that tweak did, really, was make sniping long distances easier.

[Stev0esque]

Re: hit reg

I dont think they are perfect, but I see where he is coming from, its probably good for him but not everyone.

[[GCA]Tim270]

Re: hit reg

I don't remember it being a major "selling point" at all. In fact, I don't even remember it being part of the patch.

http://blogs.battlefield.ea.com/bf2_2142/archive/2009/08/27/battlefield-2-update-v1-50-is-almost-here.aspx

A little bit less than half way down the "Gameplay tweaks" list:
"- Tweaked the hit detection, hits will be more accurate to the model."

Not even bolded, or on the top of the list. Not "overhauled the hit detection", just a simple "tweak".

Plus, this was about hit detection being accurate to the model NOT "hits not registering at all, period."

You guys are complaining about the part that I bolded, NOT the part that I italicized.

Yeah because the 3 guys who were working on it are really going to spend the time overhauling the hit detection?

Well If I was not complaining about it before, I will now.

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8Zfyx5q9kI&feature=related[/media]

Im yet to see any drastic difference in 1.5

[Minmaster]

Re: hit reg

sorry Tomeis, you're digging yourself a deeper hole.

you'd be foolish not to admit there is some sort of hit detection problem in the game.

it was evident from the first day i played BF2; if you have never experienced hit reg problems, we're not playing the same game here.

sorry bud.

[jesus]

Re: hit reg

sorry Tomeis, you're digging yourself a deeper hole.

you'd be foolish not to admit there is some sort of hit detection problem in the game.

it was evident from the first day i played BF2; if you have never experienced hit reg problems, we're not playing the same game here.

sorry bud.

Sorry that it's not a problem for me. Never once have I complained about hit detection, and I've played games like CS, CSS, TF2 and CoD4.

God forbid someone else being able to play the game with out any problems.

[lewdis]

Re: hit reg

I play with Tomeis all the time, and I don't have any problems either... maybe it's something on our end, like our internet connection.