Rank the 6 City Maps

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rob848
    Member
    • Jun 2007
    • 389

    #1

    Rank the 6 City Maps

    1. Ghost Town

    Dice got a lot better at map design with SF. The key to Ghost Town's brilliance is that the city itself is roughly circular in shape. There is a flag in the center and five around it, so the battles take place in many different areas: on the spokes of the wheel between convoy and the other flags, and along the rim between the other flags. This works much better that certain, more linear maps where all of the fighting takes place in a narrow area *cough*karkandhotel*cough* between two flags.

    2. Warlord

    More linear than ghost town but still more open and spread out than Karkand. The SAS parachute spawn helps get them in the city better, and the map wide enough that the city can't be easily defend from flanking attacks. Plus the palace battles are amazing.

    3. Mashtuur

    Lots of space around the city allow for circular fighting like in ghost town. Transport choppers can be put to very good use here because of the absence of attach choppers, jets, or AA. Assaulting the gas stations on the north and south sides is always fun.

    4. Jalalabad

    Something about the way the city is designed makes it really fun whether you're patrolling in a tank or ground pounding through the alleyways. Again, it's much easier for the USMC to get into the city than in certain other maps.

    5. Sharqi

    I've never really enjoyed sharqi that much, I think the attack choppers kind of ruin it. The openness of the city makes it hard to survive as infantry. It's still a pretty good map with a circular city shape.

    And you've probably figured out where I'm going with this...

    6. Karkand

    Vehicles or IO, there's no bigger mosh pit in BF2 than the streets of Karkand. There is exactly one for the USMC to assault the city: head on. In IO the thousands of grenades thrown every round make it impossible to survive more than thirty seconds, and in vehicles mode, the artillery is devastating because the map is so narrow. Even when the US breaks through, the city is so full of choke points *cough* bridge *cough* that every battle becomes a nadefest of the worst kind. The only reason people play Karkand is so they can get hundreds of points reviving their teammates that are getting blown up by the truckload.
  • Skaggy
    Member
    • Feb 2007
    • 1974

    #2
    My Opinion

    1.Mashtuur
    2.Karkand
    3.Sharqi
    4.Ghost Town
    5.Jellybabybad
    6.Warlord

    Comment

    • iQue
      Member
      • May 2007
      • 4925

      #3
      1. Karkand (as long as it's 32 player or less)
      2. Warlord
      3. Ghost Town
      4. Sharqi
      5. Jalalabad
      6. Mashtuur

      Comment

      • waaah_wah
        TEAM BLADE!
        • Jun 2007
        • 3656

        #4
        Originally posted by -(UtC)- Iquere «
        1. Karkand (as long as it's 32 player or less)2. Warlord
        3. Ghost Town
        4. Sharqi
        5. Jalalabad
        6. Mashtuur
        Spot on! Karkand is great with less than 32 players. Jalalabad is also a great map

        Comment

        • Hellsent 2.0
          Member
          • Jul 2007
          • 2137

          #5
          theres 6 city maps!?!?!? all ive ever seen is Karkand........

          Comment

          • Devious_Red

            #6
            1. Karkand - Excellent infantry and vehicle play. It's pretty much where I learned all of my ground pounding tricks.

            2. Mashtuur - This probably would've been number one if they hadn't nerfed the Black Hawk, but it's still a very fun map for both infantry and vehicles.

            3. Warlord - Palace battles are the best parts of this game. You can snipe from the balconies, rain down machine gun fire in the front balcony, scale the roofs and climb through the windows, and get some intense close up fighting.

            4. Sharqi - Attack choppers make this an extremely fun map, and there are good infantry battles as well.

            5. Ghost - This would probably be number 4 if the fog in the sky wasn't so awful, and I have a hard time getting the chopper to stay at a reasonable height...

            6. Jalalabad - Meh... It's OK. Fighting for the Market and Mosque are kinda fun, but it's basically a combo of all of the other city maps, except with out most of the awesome.

            Comment

            • Jlspence
              Member
              • Oct 2005
              • 502

              #7
              1. Mashtuur
              2. Warlord
              3. Sharqi
              4. Ghost Town
              5. Karkand
              6. Jalalabad

              Comment

              • RUDEnKRUDE

                #8
                I play in a cafe, so have to get what i'm given. I did play SF Warlord once and nearly wet myself with excitement.

                I also get a bit faddy. Every few months I favour a mix of pure IO, armour, landscape or city maps.

                I also prefer small-medium maps, cos I hate runnin round like an out of breath noooooooooob.

                My choice: All IO

                1. Sharqi
                2. Jalallallallbaaaabd
                3. Karkand
                4. Mashtur

                Mashtur is a sniper's soggy-dream, thus the low rating. Enough peeps know how to break Karkand to make it interesting - and I've nothing against mud pies on the bridge.

                Interesting IO maps are Oman & Daqing. The general know-how on cracking them is low, and whore-points for camping still to be exploited.

                Comment

                • DTPleeoswald
                  Member
                  • Jul 2007
                  • 536

                  #9
                  karkand
                  jala
                  mashtuur
                  warlord
                  ghost town
                  sharqi

                  Comment

                  • Iwantcable
                    Member
                    • Jul 2007
                    • 2362

                    #10
                    1. Warlord
                    2. Sharqi
                    3. Mashtuur
                    4. Ghost Town
                    5. Jalalabad
                    6. Karkand

                    Comment

                    • Adamshannon8

                      #11
                      1.Kark
                      2.Mashtuur
                      3.Sharqi
                      4.Jala
                      5.Warlord
                      6.Ghost Town

                      Comment

                      • Jezzzay

                        #12
                        Bacon

                        Depends on what you are looking for to be honest.
                        1. Mashtuur
                        2. Sharqi
                        3. Warlord
                        4. Jalalabad
                        5. Ghost Town
                        6. Karkand

                        Comment

                        • Spik3d
                          Member
                          • Feb 2006
                          • 4890

                          #13
                          1-3, I'll play. 4-6, I refuse to play.
                          1. Sharqi
                          2. Mashtuur
                          3. Ghost Town
                          4. Jalalabad
                          5. Warlord
                          6. Karkand

                          Comment

                          • Jumintiger
                            Member
                            • May 2006
                            • 517

                            #14
                            1. Warlord
                            2. Ghost Town
                            3. Mashtuur
                            4. Jalalalalabad
                            5. Karkand
                            6. Sharqi

                            Warlord is like Karkand with special forces guns and less nade spam. Distances are longer so it is more tactical and grenades are harder to use. The fights in the palace are fantastic, whichever side you're on.

                            Karkand, I just hate...It ALWAYS begins with the team raining grenades on the other team. It's a cheap way of getting kills IMO.

                            Comment

                            • sgt.collins

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Hellsent
                              theres 6 city maps!?!?!? all ive ever seen is Karkand........
                              thats because you don't have special forces....

                              Comment

                              Working...