Your most overrated and underrated maps

[Gav]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Over-rated: Clean Sweep (takes US an age to get to the island, and when they do they mostly die immediately), and Zatar (hate that map - infantry hasn't got a prayer of surviving, and all too often you're forced to walk because of no vehicles)

Under-rated: Night Flight (I know some people hate night maps, but that one is genius), and Sharqi (similar mainly-infantry feel to the combat as Karkand, with flags reasonably close together, but with more vehicles, more variety to the terrain, and no one flag that everyone seems to fight over whilst all the other flags fall - plus the attacking side having three spawns instead of one in Karkand means the assault can come from several different directions).

I also love Warlord (probably my favourite map, actually), but most people appear to know that's a good map, so I wouldn't call it "under-rated" because it doesn't get neglected the way Night Flight and Sharqi do...

[imported_Boots]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Sharqi is hardly neglected.

Actually, it compromises 75% of the maps that my clan plays... lol

[Gav]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

I know it's a popular map, Boots, but what I meant was that, compared to Karkand, Sharqi is under-rated.

[PC_Judge]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated - Strike at Karkand and Sharqi
Underrated - Daqing Oilfields and Gulf of Oman

[Flares]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Over - Karkand.
Under - Songhua.

[kenof2142]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated: Karkand
Underrated: Devils perch, leviathan, night flight

I swear up and down the night maps are a challange and add something to the gameplay which is darkness (no, I'm not talking about Charlie Murphy :p ). We have DP and leviathan in our server and it usually gets more full. The 1.22 patch, I believe, helped night vision a TON. If you haven't played a night map since 1.22 I highly suggest it.

[Eviscereightor]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated: Wake

Underrated: Daqing Oilfields

[MrChris_CJ]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

overrated : Karkand

Under: Oman - i love being a sniper on oman its by far the most fun map in the gamr imo

[venny]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated: Karkand
UnderRated: Sharqi, Oman
damn, i like Sharqi choppers, n oman tanks!

[Pace]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

OMG How can you say that about Karkland...

If your good then its complete ownage...

I cant get more points on any other map than Kark... best is about 178+ up to now but im not joking ive seen 300+ on that map... not seen that on others. Pers pref I suppose. I love flyin but the high points of Kark get you through your ranks + awards rapido

http://www.bf2player.com/index.php?page=stats&account=61024713&show=all-e

[JonnyMacFred102]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Karkand is the place to go if you can really own. Extremely skilled infantry players can own half the other team sometimes. It's a great test for good infantry players. If you want to tank whore, this is the place to do it (although armor whoring doesn't prove taht you are any good).

Wake is the place to go if you are a good chopper/airplane pilot. Just get in a cobra or j10 and whore up the bases.

[sknight]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated - I HATE WAKE. I mean, i keep going to it, thinking it will be different everytime, but it usually disappoints. I also want to note that I dislike Zatar b/c of travel times and outrageous amounts of armor battles. Maybe when I try out armor I will like it.

Underrated - FuShe has some fun no matter what size map it is.

[Slacker317]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated: Wake & Ghost Town
Underrated: Songhua Stalemate & Night Flight

I love Songhua because it's the closest we have to jungled maps like BF:V had. Night Flight is just the best of the night maps, and night maps are underrated in general.

Wake is PLA raping the USMC carrier until they FINALLY cap (good luck if the USMC air support is too busy in dog fights) and tends to become a sniper fest. Ghost Town just seems to be played too much in SF, IMO. I find the teams to be stacked the most in Ghost Town than any other map, yet everyone calls it a balanced map. [shrug]
Honorable overrated mention to Iron Gator. It would be a good map, but I can't play it due to the slide show I get once on the carrier.

[imported_Walker]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

Overrated: Karkand
Underrated: Mashpotato City - Much superior to Karkand.

[MrChris_CJ]

Re: Your most overrated and underrated maps

OMG How can you say that about Karkland...

If your good then its complete ownage...

I cant get more points on any other map than Kark... best is about 178+ up to now but im not joking ive seen 300+ on that map... not seen that on others. Pers pref I suppose. I love flyin but the high points of Kark get you through your ranks + awards rapido

http://www.bf2player.com/index.php?p...713&show=all-e

yeh i think we're talking about gameplay here not how many people you can revive/heal in a round to get points with...