No announcement yet.

Much Ado About Loot Boxes


  • Much Ado About Loot Boxes

    Loot box
    Once again, the hot topic of video game loot boxes finds itself in the spotlight. This past week the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced their plans to investigate loot boxes. They cite concerns over the potential impact of children.

    In response, the Entertainment Software Association (ESA) doubled down on their stance that loot boxes can "enhance the experience." They claim that the loot boxes are not anywhere close to traditional gambling, which you can practice using betting apps for example, and are fine with leaving things as they are. However, the International Game Developers Association (IGDA) have said that it's time for the entire industry to step in and self-regulate before the government does it for them.

    The FTC's reasoning for wanting to investigate loot boxes is to protect children. Specifically, they want to "investigate loot box mechanisms, to ensure that children are being adequately protected, and to educate parents about potential addiction or other negative impacts of these games." These specifics were brought up from Senator Maggie Hassan (D-NH).

    ESA Buries Its Head in the Sand
    On the flip side, the ESA said that "loot boxes are one way players can enhance the experience that video games offer."
    "Contrary to assertions, loot boxes are not gambling. They have no real-world value, players always receive something that enhances their experience, and they are entirely optional to purchase. They can enhance the experience for those who choose to use them, but have no impact on those who do not."

    It is very easy to see how the ESA's thinking is disingenuous at best and dangerous at worst. To say that loot boxes "have no impact" for those that do not purchase them is often a fabrication. Yes, many loot boxes contain only cosmetic item, but very often they still include gameplay altering items. Even those that only contain cosmetics hold a certain appeal to gamers. Some items cannot be obtained through the typical gameplay progression. Others can only be obtained after multiple hours of grinding. In these cases, the appeal of a cosmetic shortcut can be just as strong as obtaining game altering items. Consumers often feel pressured to get these limited or hard to obtain items. It is especially egregious in games that are not free-to-play to begin with.

    The most that the ESA has done that could be seen as a good way to keep children away from loot boxes is to add an "In-Game Purchases" designation on ESRB ratings. It's vague enough to remain questionable but "just enough" to make it seem like they care.

    The IGDA Responds
    The IGDA, by way of a blog post from executive director Jen MacLean, says that there are three simple steps that industry can take to help regulate loot boxes in games, especially games that are played by children.
    1. Affirm an industry commitment to not market loot boxes to children
    2. Clearly disclose the odds of different rewards when purchasing loot boxes (as many games already do to comply with Chinese law)
    3. Launch a coordinated education campaign that boosts awareness of the parental controls that are available to appropriately limit how players engage with games

    These seem like simple requests, but there is obvious opposition to any sort of regulations. Let's face it, publishers and developers want loot boxes to be accessible to as many people as possible. However, there is no reason why those who are not of legal gambling age should ever have unregulated access to them.
      Posting comments is disabled.





    Latest Articles


    • Discord Store Moves to Give Developers 90% of Sales Revenue
      Shawn Zipay
      In the new war on crappy revenue splits, Discord announced today that they are going to allow all developers to self-publish their games. Not only that, but they're going to give developers a 90% revenue share for games sold through the Discord Store. That leaves just the remaining 10% for Discord to cover operating costs.

      But wait, it gets even better.

      Discord says that they may even end up lowering that 10% to a smaller amount by finding ways to optimize their technology and making things more efficient.
      Earlier this year though, we noticed
      12-15-2018, 02:34 AM
    • Rockstar Begins Selling Gold Bars for Real Money in Red Dead Online
      Shawn Zipay
      I guess the beta for Red Dead Online is "good" enough now that Rockstar felt comfortable opening up their real-money store for the game. Starting today, you can purchase gold bars to fulfill Red Dead Online's second economy. These bars allow you to purchase various in-game items such as horses, outfits, weapon customizations, and more without spending the other in-game currency of "RDO$" or Red Dead Online dollars. The prices for gold bars begins at $9.99 (USD), which will net you 25 gold bars. However, they do have a special that you can get...
      12-14-2018, 08:04 PM
    • Below is Out Now from Capy Games
      Shawn Zipay
      It's been a long road but Below is finally out on the Xbox One and on PC via Steam. Crawl some challenging dungeons in this gorgeous uh, well, dungeon crawler.

      Below has been in development since at least 2013 when it was shown off during Microsoft's E3 presentation.
      Test your adventurer mettle against The Isle’s procedural subterranean labyrinths. Explore a large, interconnected underworld crawling with cunning creatures, deadly traps, and a mysterious shadowy presence. Survive the perils of The Depths and unearth what
      12-14-2018, 06:37 PM
    • Metro Exodus Release Date Moved Up to February 15, 2019
      Shawn Zipay
      4A Games and Deep Silver announced that after five years of being in development, Metro Exodus has gone gold and is set to release a week earlier than original anticipated. The new release date is February 15, 2019 for the Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and PC.

      To celebrate the good news, Deep Silver released the title sequence for Metro Exodus, which you can find below.
      Created by Santa Monica-based studio, Elastic, the award-winning makers of some of the most iconic title sequences of recent years including Game of Thrones and Westworld, this beautiful introduction to the game is set to an original score by Metro series composer Alexey Omelchuk. “We were absolutely thrilled to
      12-13-2018, 11:17 PM
    • Hunt: Showdown Update 4.0 Adds New Game Mode
      Shawn Zipay
      The 4.0 update for Hunt: Showdown is out today. This new update adds in the Quickplay game mode, additional challenges, some changes to the weapons, and more.

      Check out the full details on Hunt: Showdown's 4.0 update.
      Early access development means constant updates, and today Crytek have released another big one for their early access online multiplayer bounty hunting game, Hunt: Showdown. In conjunction with the new release, Hunt: Showdown will be on sale for 25% off on Steam from December 13 at 10 am PT/ 1 pm ET/ 7 pm CEST to December 19 at
      12-13-2018, 11:02 PM
    • Final Fantasy XV Multiplayer: Comrades Now Available as Standalone Release
      Shawn Zipay
      A standalone version of the multiplayer component to Final Fantasy XV, Comrades, was just released today. It's out now for the Xbox One and PlayStation 4 versions of the game. There is no standalone PC release for this.

      In addition, there is a crossover event between Final Fantasy XV and Final Fantasy XIV to talk about here.
      In the FINAL FANTASY XV MULTIPLAYER: COMRADES standalone edition, available for the Xbox One family of devices including Xbox One X and the PlayStation®4 computer entertainment system, players can partake in
      12-13-2018, 10:09 PM